Confused about collagen vs elastin for skin stuff
Posted by fasted_scientist in Beginner Questions - 34 points, 6 comments.
I have been reading up on some of the skin stuff lately and I am a bit lost on where to actually start. I am looking into /peptides/collagen-peptides and /peptides/elastin-peptides because I want to try and improve my skin texture and maybe help with some fine lines.
Ngl it is a bit overwhelming with all the different types. I see people talking about taking collagen orally in large amounts like 10g or 15g a day, but then I see elastin being used topically or in smaller doses. I am trying to figure out if they are actually doing different things or if it is just marketing fluff.
From what I have gathered, collagen seems to be more about the structure and hydration, while elastin is more about the bounce and resilience. But I cannot tell if I should be looking for a combo or if one is just better than the other to start with. Does anyone here actually use both? I am keen to get a proper handle on the basics before I spend any money on anything. If anyone has a simple way to look at these protocols without getting bogged down in the heavy science, I would appreciate it.
Comments
- lena_gains: It is quite a mess of information out there. Imo your assessment is mostly correct about the roles they play. Collagen provides the scaffolding and elastin allows for that snap back, so they work together in the dermal matrix. I have tried taking collagen peptides orally for several months. For me, it seemed to help slightly with skin hydration, but I did not notice a massive change in fine lines. I also used a topical GHK-Cu serum which I felt had a more noticeable effect on my skin texture th
- optimizer_jenna: I actually had a similar experience with GHK-Cu. For me, it seemed to do MUCH more for the texture of my skin than oral collagen ever did, though it could just be placebo. Do you have any links to papers that compare the two? I am always skeptical of these claims without a good citation, tbh.
- optimizer_jenna: I agree that the information is a mess, tbh. I also tried GHK-Cu recently and it seemed to work better for my skin texture than oral supplements. Since I am quite skeptical of marketing, do you have any citations or a specific study that shows GHK-Cu is actually superior to collagen for texture? I would love to read more about it.
- fasted_scientist: Ngl I haven't looked into GHK-Cu yet, I was just stuck on the collagen and elastin side of things. I don't have any citations for it because I'm just now hearing about it from you. I reckon I'll check for some actual data on it, but for now I'm still trying to figure out if the 10g oral collagen doses actually do anything or if it's all just hype.
- fasted_scientist: Ngl I am in the same boat with the skepticism. I have not found any proper papers that directly compare oral collagen to something like GHK-Cu yet. I was mostly looking at the structural side of things, but your point about GHK-Cu doing more for texture is interesting. Do you reckon the GHK-Cu worked better because it was topical, or is it just a more potent compound for skin repair?
- fasted_scientist: Ngl I reckon you are spot on about the scaffolding vs snap back thing. It makes sense that they work together. I was a bit gutted to hear you didn't see much change in your fine lines with the oral collagen, though. I am still leaning towards trying the oral stuff first since it is easier than a serum. Do you think the GHK-Cu worked better because it was topical, or just because it is a different type of compound altogether?
Community discussion - research and educational context only. Not medical advice.